Our Menu
Delivery extra. Prices subject to change without notice and subject to New York state
sales tax. drivers do not carry coin change. And please have the porch light on. thanks!
Pizza
Available with Red or White sauce, and Regular or Thin crust • People love our delicious homemade hand-tossed pizza. Whether it be the huge pizza slices or one of our many regular or specialty pizza pies, you’ll find the freshest and finest ingredients.
Small 9” with Cheese
Medium 12” with Cheese
Large 16” with Cheese
Half Sheet 17” x 12” with Cheese
Full Sheet 17” x 24” with Cheese
Toppings
Specialty Pizza
Goody Two Shoes Special
Mafioso Pizza
Pepperoni Lover’s Pizza
Veggie Pizza
Chicken Wing Pizza
Meat Lover’s Pizza
Wings
Mr. Shoes serves only premium jumbo or boneless chicken wings with homemade sauces. All orders include our own bleu cheese dressing • Served with your choice of sauce: Buffalo (Hot, Medium, or Mild), Sweet ‘n’ Sour, Boss Sauce, Garlic Parmesan, or BBQ | Please specify Jumbo or Boneless wings when ordering | Extra Blue Cheese or Wing Sauce +$1.00
Wings (5)
Wings (10)
Wings (50)
Breaded Wings (10)
Breaded Wing Dinner
Calzones
Our calzones are made with homemade pizza dough, generously filled with your choice of Cheese, Meats, or Veggies, and oven-baked to perfection. Choose one of our favorites or create your own custom calzone | Calzones come with 2 pizza sauces on the side (sauce substitutions extra) • Extra items +$1.50 | Extra Pizza Sauce (each) +$0.75 | Extra Bleu Cheese or Wing Sauce +$1.00
Custom Calzone
Buffalo Chicken Calzone
Cheese Calzone (3)
Veggie Calzone
Meat Lover’s Calzone
Mr. Shoes Dinners
Spaghetti
Baked Lasagna
Chicken Parmigiana
Side of Meatballs (2)
Fish Fry
Chicken Finger (4) Dinner
Mr. Shoes Plates
Mr. Shoes grills Zweigle’s red hots exclusively. Our Plates have been judged by those who are known as “Best in Town.” | All plates come with bread and butter.
Mr. Shoes “Rochester Style” Burger & Hot Dog Plates
Hamburger Plate
Cheeseburger Plate
Hot Dog Plate
Combo Plate
From the Grill
Topping choices: Lettuce | Tomato | Onion | Pickles | Relish | Mustard | Ketchup | Mayo | House-Made Meat Hot Sauce
Cheddar Mushroom Burger
Hamburger
Cheeseburger
Double Cheeseburger
Hot Dog
Gourmet Subs
Mr. Shoes offers a huge assortment of cold and hot specialty subs, served with all of your favorite toppings. Our sub rolls are fresh baked daily and our meats are the highest quality.
Timmy 2 Shoes Sausage & Steak Slammer
Cajun Black ‘N’ Blue Steak Bomber
Two Step Chicken & Bacon
Sweet & Sassy Chicken Finger Sub
Blue Suede Buffalo Chicken
Shoe Be Do Be Do - Steak
Gourmet Bread Bowl Salads
Try our famous bread bowl salads: hand-tossed pizza dough is freshly baked and filled with fresh lettuce, veggies, homemade croutons, and your choice of Meats and Cheeses.
Buffalo Chicken
Garden
Julienne
Caesar
Chicken Caesar
Crispy Chicken
Grilled Chicken & Bacon
Hot Subs
All subs are custom-made to order. Please specify topping choices and cheese upon ordering.
Buttered Steak
Grilled Chicken Breast with Cheese
Meatball with Mozzarella & Sauce
Chicken Parmigiana with Mozzarella & Sauce
Chicken Finger
Fresh Salads
All salads come with onions, black olives, tomatoes, croutons, and cheddar cheese • Dressing choices: Balsamic Vinaigrette | Bleu Cheese, Ranch | Thousand Island | French | Caesar | Honey Mustard | Italian | Creamy Italian
Garden
Julienne
Caesar
Sides
Our sides are the perfect addition to our pizza, wings, and sub-specialties. Indulge with some loaded French fries, or order a side of garlic cheese bread with your Salad or Pasta dinner.
Side Order Combo
Pizza Logs (5)
Loaded French Fries
Loaded Potato Skins
French Fries
Onion Rings
Jalapeno Poppers (5)
Batter Fried Cauliflower
Mozzarella Sticks (5)
Fried Mushrooms
Garlic Bread
Garlic Bread with Mozzarella
Bread Stix
Bread Stix with Mozzarella
Macaroni Salad
Cajun Beans
Side Salad
Cold Subs
All subs are custom-made to order. Please specify topping choices and cheese upon ordering • Sub topping choices: Lettuce, Tomatoes, Onions, Mustard, Horseradish, Oil, or Mayo | Your choice of cheese: Provolone, American, Pepper Jack, or Swiss.
Turkey Breast
Ham
Tuna
Italian Assorted
Veggie
Save Room for Dessert
Save room for dessert! Try our addictively delicious Cinnamon Toes: homemade pizza dough, deep-fried and covered with cinnamon and sugar.